Monday, March 30, 2009
Wanting it both ways
3/30/2009 02:06:00 PM |
Posted by
JoeSettler |
Edit Post
If only the issue was that the secular Neturei Karta - the left wing of Israel, wanted a fair division of burden in Israel, then at least I could understand their calls to draft Chareidi Jews into the army.
But unfortunately that isn't the case, after all, can the far left really expect the Chareidi populace to join the armed forces, while completely and utterly not only disregarding their needs, but attempting to force secular coercion down their throats?
I mean, it would certainly appear to the Chareidim that the goal is not to share the military burden, but to inculcate their youth with non-Jewish values (to say the least).
And they would be right.
Let's ignore for a minute the self-righteous left wing attacks against the IDF Rabbinate and IDF Chief Rabbi Ronsky (a former Special Forces officer) for daring to provide Jewish motivations to our Jewish soldiers in a Jewish army during the war.
Let's instead look at the recent attacks on the religious Ben"nish (Bnei Yeshiva) soldiers.
Recently, the IDF provided musical entertainment to various units in the form of secular singers and music.
The religious soldiers, yeshiva students all, stepped out of the show for the female singers, feeling that it was religiously inappropriate for them to be there.
And the Left blasted them.
No one thought, from the IDF entertainment manager, to the far left kvetchers, that maybe the venue was inappropriate for religious soldiers, instead they attacked religious soldiers for not participating in their party.
Is it any wonder the Chareidi citizen doesn't want any part of the army if all they see are attempts at secular coercion and hypocrisy?
(Oh, and if you are thinking of responding by discussing Chareidi motivations for not joining - don't. The point of this post is the demand for Chareidim to join the IDF, but then using the army as a club in an overt attempt at secular coercion as well as attacking the religious in the army because they won't conform to the secular's mores).
But unfortunately that isn't the case, after all, can the far left really expect the Chareidi populace to join the armed forces, while completely and utterly not only disregarding their needs, but attempting to force secular coercion down their throats?
I mean, it would certainly appear to the Chareidim that the goal is not to share the military burden, but to inculcate their youth with non-Jewish values (to say the least).
And they would be right.
Let's ignore for a minute the self-righteous left wing attacks against the IDF Rabbinate and IDF Chief Rabbi Ronsky (a former Special Forces officer) for daring to provide Jewish motivations to our Jewish soldiers in a Jewish army during the war.
Let's instead look at the recent attacks on the religious Ben"nish (Bnei Yeshiva) soldiers.
Recently, the IDF provided musical entertainment to various units in the form of secular singers and music.
The religious soldiers, yeshiva students all, stepped out of the show for the female singers, feeling that it was religiously inappropriate for them to be there.
And the Left blasted them.
No one thought, from the IDF entertainment manager, to the far left kvetchers, that maybe the venue was inappropriate for religious soldiers, instead they attacked religious soldiers for not participating in their party.
Is it any wonder the Chareidi citizen doesn't want any part of the army if all they see are attempts at secular coercion and hypocrisy?
(Oh, and if you are thinking of responding by discussing Chareidi motivations for not joining - don't. The point of this post is the demand for Chareidim to join the IDF, but then using the army as a club in an overt attempt at secular coercion as well as attacking the religious in the army because they won't conform to the secular's mores).
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
►
2012
(1)
- ► December 2012 (1)
-
►
2011
(44)
- ► October 2011 (1)
- ► September 2011 (3)
- ► August 2011 (5)
- ► April 2011 (5)
- ► March 2011 (7)
- ► February 2011 (6)
- ► January 2011 (6)
-
►
2010
(109)
- ► December 2010 (4)
- ► November 2010 (7)
- ► October 2010 (10)
- ► September 2010 (8)
- ► August 2010 (9)
- ► April 2010 (11)
- ► March 2010 (9)
- ► February 2010 (12)
- ► January 2010 (12)
-
▼
2009
(277)
- ► December 2009 (14)
- ► November 2009 (14)
- ► October 2009 (17)
- ► September 2009 (19)
- ► August 2009 (17)
- ► April 2009 (18)
-
▼
March 2009
(34)
- The Cellcom Scam
- Wanting it both ways
- Sick, sick, sick
- Too much moderation
- A Thank You Letter to Moshe
- Is the Red-Dead a Dead-End?
- Sleeping Well
- Water Water Everywhere
- Firs
- The "Aggressive" IDF Soldier
- How Revealing
- Antisemitic?!
- Caroline Glick Makes a Mistake
- Israel Stands Alone
- Kids do the darndest things
- First Thought (Part 2)
- National Union - An initial success
- The Two-State Solution
- The Attitude of Ingratitude
- It's about time
- It's like Purim in the real world
- This is not a Purim Post
- Regifting
- Boycott Alerts
- 2 Monkeys
- Barkat Defends Jerusalem
- Blot out any remembrance of Amalek
- Sins of Omission
- Those Whacky Chareidim (2)
- Barak, Barak
- Does Leiberman Understand Arabic?
- Ending the Threat
- Wards of the State World
- The Norwegian Law
- ► February 2009 (32)
- ► January 2009 (29)
-
►
2008
(390)
- ► December 2008 (47)
- ► November 2008 (24)
- ► October 2008 (33)
- ► September 2008 (41)
- ► August 2008 (20)
- ► April 2008 (27)
- ► March 2008 (40)
- ► February 2008 (29)
- ► January 2008 (28)
-
►
2007
(318)
- ► December 2007 (14)
- ► November 2007 (26)
- ► October 2007 (25)
- ► September 2007 (20)
- ► August 2007 (32)
- ► April 2007 (31)
- ► March 2007 (34)
- ► February 2007 (28)
- ► January 2007 (18)
-
►
2006
(333)
- ► December 2006 (16)
- ► November 2006 (19)
- ► October 2006 (12)
- ► September 2006 (21)
- ► August 2006 (54)
- ► April 2006 (11)
- ► March 2006 (25)
- ► February 2006 (22)
- ► January 2006 (52)
-
►
2005
(88)
- ► December 2005 (32)
- ► November 2005 (18)
- ► October 2005 (5)
- ► September 2005 (12)
- ► August 2005 (21)
3 comments:
excellant!!
you could also add that not only are the 1 milion secular yordim not serving , but numbers show an ever increasing deferral rate among Israel living seculars.
I am all for Chareidim joining the IDF and serving to protect their country. There already are Chareidi units which are very successful.
I just read an article on Arutz Sheva about renovations being made at the main officer's training base, to accomodate frum families of frum soldiers. They are also adding separate swimming times for men and women (they are re-activating their pool, which hadn't been used for a while).
So, it's not that the army is trying to influence dati soldiers to secular ways; just that they are unaware of the halacha, or haven't thought of putting in halachically permitted entertainment.
Quite the contrary, I think it's VERY important for datiim to serve (including Chareidim); it sets a wonderful example for the hilonim.
According to that article, 25% of IDF soldiers (training to be officers) are dati.
How about that?!
Post a Comment